New executives must immediately understand and evaluate a company’s culture before launching any significant change initiatives. They must ask themselves: Is this the right culture for the future? And given the current values, norms and beliefs of the company, how can I best implement change and build the foundation for sustainable success?
Implementing change is never easy, but for a newly hired executive working with new people in a new culture, the challenge is even greater.
Understanding the current culture of the company is an important first step. What are the norms, values and beliefs of the company? Who are its informal leaders?
Dissecting the company’s organizational model is key. Some companies are mechanistic, in which people are viewed as cogs in a machine. ‘Legitimate’ leadership — that is, leadership based on the organizational chart — and a focus on extrinsic motivation, such as raises and bonuses, are standard features of mechanistic companies.
Other companies are organic, in which the company is considered a living, social organism, and responding to the intrinsic motivations of people — their deeply felt desires and hopes — is fundamental to its success. Leadership in organic companies is not legitimate or transactional, as in mechanistic companies, but more traditional: leaders must earn authority and respect through a consensus of their subordinates.
Finally, companies might be anthropological, in which pursuing social values is a major component of their purpose. These companies require charismatic, transformative leadership.
Assessing the company’s culture and organizational model will help new executives decide whether the culture needs changing in order to achieve their goals — and if so, how to implement that change.
In a mechanistic company, a new leader has immediate authority simply by receiving the title of CEO. Thus, reactive change — a fast, top-down, push approach to implementing change — can work within this type of company.
In organic or anthropological companies, reactive change will be met with fierce resistance. Leaders cannot mandate change. Instead, they must use ‘soft power’ by first building up their credibility with people in the organization. Showing respect to the company’s culture and values, as well as becoming close with the company’s informal leaders, will enable new leaders to build up credibility points. The new CEOs can then work on proactive change — a bottom-up strategy in which small incremental changes accumulate into a broader change of culture.
Professor Guido Stein of IESE and IESE research assistants Alberto Ortiz and Mara Cuadrado offer in their paper Business Culture in the Incorporation of a New Executive a 10-point checklist for new executives looking to make a successful cultural ‘landing’:
Business Culture in the Incorporation of a New Executive. Alberto Ortiz Pizarro, Guido Stein Martinez & Marta Cuadrado. IESE Technical Note (January 2016).
Ideas for Leaders is a free-to-access site. If you enjoy our content and find it valuable, please consider subscribing to our Developing Leaders Quarterly publication, this presents academic, business and consultant perspectives on leadership issues in a beautifully produced, small volume delivered to your desk four times a year.
For the less than the price of a coffee a week you can read over 650 summaries of research that cost universities over $1 billion to produce.
Use our Ideas to:
Speak to us on how else you can leverage this content to benefit your organization. firstname.lastname@example.org