Online Customers Reviews: Loyalty and Deception - Ideas for Leaders
Idea #356

Online Customers Reviews: Loyalty and Deception

This is one of our free-to-access content pieces. To gain access to all Ideas for Leaders content please Log In Here or if you are not already a Subscriber then Subscribe Here.
Main Image
Main Image


While it might seem easy for competitors to hurt a rival’s sales by posting negative reviews, research reveals that many of the most negative product reviews are written by loyal customers trying to influence company strategy. 


Many Internet retailers give customers the opportunity to review their products on their site, and some Internet companies even specialize in reviews only (e.g. Yelp and TripAdvisor). Given, as research shows, the impact that online customer reviews can have on the success of a product or service, it is no wonder that special attention is paid to the legitimacy of the reviews. One fear is that competitors will post negative reviews on the site for the obvious purpose of moving the company’s customers to their products, a concern with merit.

However, when Eric Anderson of Kellogg and Duncan Simester of MIT Sloan researched the negative reviews on the site of a private label apparel company, they made two unexpected discoveries. First, they discovered, after rigorous analysis of the data supported by linguistic analysis of the reviews, that many of the negative reviews were written by people who had not purchased the product.

Yet, these were the reviewers who were the most negative about the product; reviewer who did not purchase the product rated that product with twice as many 1’s (the lowest rating) as reviewers who had purchased the product.

The second discovery was even more startling: these negative reviews were written by valuable customers. Reviewers who had not purchased the product they reviewed had lower household incomes and less education than reviewers who had confirmed purchases. However, the reviewers without a purchase were higher volume customers. While they had not bought the product they reviewed, they purchased 30% more items than reviewers who had a confirmed purchase record, even though they may have been customers for a slightly shorter period.

Why would loyal customers post negative reviews of products they didn’t buy? An analysis of the data leads to three possible explanations:

  1. The customer had a bad experience with the company and decided to write a review as retribution.
  2. The customer wants to act as self-appointed brand manager, sees a product online that they don’t approve of, and write a negative review to offer their opinion.
  3. The customer uses the act of writing reviews as a chance to enhance their social status.

The data suggests that the first two are more likely explanations for many of the negative reviews.


Very few customers write reviews. In this case of this firm, for every 1,000 customers, 15 wrote reviews, and only 1 wrote a review without a confirmed transaction. However, that 1 out of a 1,000 still represented 12,000 reviewers posting a total of 15,000 negative reviews on the firm’s site. And those 15,000 negative reviews have an impact. Sales of products negatively reviewed dipped some 2% after the review appeared. (Unfortunately, the negative impact of negative reviews is greater than the positive impact of positive reviews.)

What can companies do to avoid these kinds of reviews? First, don’t pursue legal action against these reviewers. They are, after all, your best customers.

Second, try to redirect the customer’s activities. Many of these reviewers just want to be heard; give them the avenue to connect with your company. If customers have an outlet for offering advice and making complaints, they are more likely to avoid the negative review process.

Finally, and most directly, require reviewers to demonstrate proof of purchase. Expedia allows only customers who have purchased the product to write a review.

Unfortunately, if a consensus emerges that only reviews linked to the actual purchase of products are legitimate, websites such as TripAdvisor or Yelp — aggregators of reviews of products they do not sell — are in trouble. In the future, review sites may want to partner with firms that can provide access to transaction information.



Ideas for Leaders is a free-to-access site. If you enjoy our content and find it valuable, please consider subscribing to our Developing Leaders Quarterly publication, this presents academic, business and consultant perspectives on leadership issues in a beautifully produced, small volume delivered to your desk four times a year.


Idea conceived

January 1, 2014

Idea posted

Apr 2014
challenge block
Can't find the Idea you are after?
Then 'Challenge Us' to source it.


For the less than the price of a coffee a week you can read over 650 summaries of research that cost universities over $1 billion to produce.

Use our Ideas to:

  • Catalyse conversations with mentors, mentees, peers and colleagues.
  • Keep program participants engaged with leadership thinking when they return to their workplace.
  • Create a common language amongst your colleagues on leadership and management practice
  • Keep up-to-date with the latest thought-leadership from the world’s leading business schools.
  • Drill-down on the original research or even contact the researchers directly

Speak to us on how else you can leverage this content to benefit your organization.