Gary Cookson understands this tension well. Gary is the Director of EPIC where he helps customers with Learning and development, Human resources, Organizational design, Business transformation, & Digital delivery. He’s a workplace and leadership expert with more than twenty-five years of experience focused on making work better for people. 

His book The Squeezed Middle examines why this layer feels stretched and why the role remains unclear in so many places. His earlier work explores hybrid and remote settings and the systems that shape how people work. 

He has studied culture, structure, relationships, and behavior, and he shows how these forces shape daily performance. His research highlights the emotional and relational work people do in the middle, from sensemaking to steady guidance. He also argues that empathy, storytelling, and reflection are core skills, not extras.

In this article, we’ll look at why middle roles feel heavy, why expectations often stay vague, and how people can build influence upward and clarity downward. 

We’ll explore the skills that keep teams steady during change, the pressures that come with unclear systems, and the steps that help Middle Managers feel supported rather than squeezed.

Why Middle Managers End Up Carrying So Much Pressure?

Middle managers sit in a tough spot. They support senior leaders and guide their teams every day. They keep work moving, but they also absorb tension from all sides. That mix clearly creates pressure. Many people feel it, even if they can’t always explain why.

Image Credits: Photo by Pavel Danilyuk on Pexels

Why does the role feel unclear

Senior leadership roles come with clear goals and clear authority. First-line managers also know their role because they focus on delivery. The middle sits between both layers, but the role rarely gets the same clarity. Most job descriptions focus on technical skills, so people think expertise defines the job.

That’s where the trouble starts. The real work goes far beyond specialist tasks. Middle managers shape culture and handle conflict. They connect teams and explain decisions. 

They support people through change, even when answers feel unclear. These duties don’t appear on paper, so many people discover them under pressure.

A simple pattern shows up:

• Technical tasks feel clear and familiar.
• Leadership expectations feel loose or implied.
• Pressure builds when that gap stays open.

Why do organizations keep repeating the same mistakes

Hybrid work made this issue harder to ignore. Many companies set simple rules about where people work. However, hybrid work needs more than schedules. It depends on structure, culture, and daily leadership habits. When these stay vague, the load shifts to the middle.

Moreover, organizations often overlook this layer. They invest heavily in senior leaders and new supervisors. Middle managers receive far less support. People step into the role without guidance and then feel stuck, stretched, and unsure.

What a clearer model can offer

A stronger approach treats the middle as a real leadership layer. It gives the role a clear purpose, not just extra tasks. Shared expectations matter here. So does clarity around communication and decision-making.

That said, even a simple structure helps. When people know what good looks like, they stop guessing. Confidence grows. Pressure drops. The role starts to feel manageable and valuable, which it definitely is.

How Can Middle Managers Build Upward Influence and Reduce Ambiguity?

Unclear expectations drain confidence fast. People can handle hard news, but uncertainty wears them down. Middle managers feel this most because they balance demands from leaders and teams. A clear structure helps people act with purpose. Ambiguity slows thinking and raises stress.

Image Credits: Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels

Why upward influence matters

Middle managers see real work every day. They spot pressure points, gaps in plans, and early signs of trouble. Senior leaders need this view to make better calls. Upward influence turns frontline reality into clear input leaders can use. Most people don’t learn this skill early, so it often feels risky at first.

Some of this skill comes from training. Workshops help with language and framing. However, confidence grows through use. People improve when they speak up, test ideas, and learn what lands well with leaders. That mix builds judgment over time.

Why peer learning strengthens the role

Middle management can feel lonely. Much of the work stays invisible, like calming anxiety, smoothing conflict, and holding teams steady. When people carry this alone, the role feels heavier than it should.

Peer learning helps because managers share what actually happens. They compare approaches and see patterns. They also realize others face the same tension. That shared view reduces doubt and builds confidence.

Helpful support usually blends a few things:

• Short formal training
• On-the-job learning
• Coaching or mentoring
• A steady peer group for real discussion

Why organizations struggle to support this

Many organizations still don’t clearly define middle-manager work. They focus on tasks and outputs, but they ignore relational work. That gap weakens change efforts. Messages get lost, and plans stall because sensemaking gets overlooked.

What effective sensemaking looks like

Strong middle managers turn confusion into clarity. They keep people steady and help ideas land well.

They focus on a few core actions:

• Calm anxiety before it spreads
• Translate strategy into simple, workable steps
• Spot cracks early and fix them fast
• Share honest feedback upward in clear terms
• Hold teams together during constant change

This work is emotional and practical. It often goes unseen. When organizations treat it as core work, pressure drops and results improve.

How Can Middle Managers Strengthen Adaptation During Change?

Change brings noise. It creates worry, confusion, and small issues that grow when no one catches them early. Middle managers often prevent those problems before others notice. The tough part is that this work sits in the background, so people assume everything is fine on its own. That gap makes the role harder than it needs to be.

Image Credits: Photo by Andrea Piacquadio on Pexels

Why storytelling matters

Storytelling helps teams understand change clearly and humanely. It turns complex plans into something people can feel and follow. When managers tell simple and honest stories, they help teams stay grounded during uncertain times.

Key skills that strengthen storytelling include:

• Empathy: Helps managers speak in a way people understand and trust.
• Curiosity: Encourages better questions, so managers see what people need.
• Reflection: Helps them slow down and explain things with real clarity.
• Emotional awareness: Guides them to choose the right tone at the right moment.

These skills help people connect with the message, not just the words. Moreover, they make change feel less cold and more meaningful.

Why time and focus still limit progress

Some managers love this work and fit it easily into their schedules. Others want to do it but struggle to find space for it. Many hoped AI would free time for real leadership, but that hasn’t happened yet. Most organizations use AI without a plan, so people end up losing time instead of gaining it.

A better way is simple. Focus AI on the few tasks that take most of a manager’s day. If those tasks shrink, managers get space for coaching, sensemaking, and steady team support.

Why systems matter

Burnout often reflects the system, not the person. Structure helps, but the wider organizational system shapes workload and pressure. When systems force people to overwork, stress climbs, and results fall.

Why middle managers drive learning

Work keeps shifting. Middle managers see these shifts early and help teams adjust. They encourage small trials, support new skills, and turn big ideas into actionable steps. That position makes them essential for building teams that stay flexible and ready for what comes next.

Are Middle Managers More Likely to Feel Fulfilled or Frustrated?

People enter middle management for very different reasons, so their experiences vary widely. Some feel settled and content. Others feel stuck or overwhelmed. A clear pattern shows up, though. People who enjoy the role now often struggle during their first attempt. 

They learned through real pressure, adjusted their expectations, and returned with a clearer view of the work. First-time managers, however, often feel frustrated because the role doesn’t match the picture they had in their minds.

Image Credits: Photo by MART  PRODUCTION on Pexels

Why expectations rarely match the real job

Most people step into middle management with an idea of what the role should offer. They expect influence, decision power, and room to shape change. 

Then they discover the work asks for something quite different. It asks for patience, listening, steady guidance, and emotional effort. It also asks for a lot of quiet problem-solving that no one notices.

That gap between belief and reality causes friction. People expect authority but find responsibility. They expect control but find complexity. However, once they understand what the role truly requires, the work feels more grounded and more rewarding.

Moreover, people usually learn this only through lived experience. They try things, struggle, reflect, and adjust. The second attempt often feels smoother because the surprises are gone.

How organizations can shape better expectations

No one should figure this out alone. Organizations can help by involving people who understand the role well.

Useful voices include:

• Senior leaders who once held middle roles
• Current managers who can describe the work honestly
• HR and learning teams that define needed skills

When these groups share real insight, new managers walk in with a clearer idea of what the job demands.

Why shared wisdom strengthens the middle

Support from experienced people makes a huge difference. They spot early signs of struggle and offer practical guidance. 

They help people interpret challenges before stress builds. This steady support turns confusion into clarity and helps new managers grow into the role with confidence.

With the right expectations and guidance, the middle stops feeling squeezed and starts feeling purposeful.

Conclusion

Middle managers carry a hard load, but this doesn’t mean the role can’t feel rewarding. When we look closely at the work, a clear truth shows up. 

They steady teams, guide people through noise, and turn unclear plans into actions that make sense. That work is real leadership, even if it doesn’t always look loud or dramatic.

However, the pressure builds quickly when people step into the role without a clear picture. They expect authority and control. They find complexity and constant demands instead. 

That gap frustrates many first-time managers, and it’s no surprise they feel stretched. With the right support, though, the role feels far more manageable.

Moreover, this support doesn’t need to be complicated. Honest guidance from experienced people helps. Time to learn and reflect helps. Simple systems that remove confusion help even more. And when organizations treat sensemaking, feedback, and emotional steadiness as core skills, confidence rises across the middle.

The future of this role depends on clarity, not heroics. When people understand what the job truly asks for, they stop guessing and start leading with purpose. They handle pressure with more calm. They support others with more ease. And they feel the impact of their work more clearly and strongly.

With the right structure and support, the middle stops feeling squeezed. It starts feeling stable, useful, and worth building a career around.

FAQs

Why do Middle Managers struggle with time for real leadership work?

Middle Managers deal with constant requests, quick fixes, and shifting plans. This noise eats their time fast. They want to coach people, but spend most days fighting fires.

What skills help Middle Managers handle tough conversations better?

Sharp listening, steady tone, and simple language help. These skills keep people calm and make hard messages easier to act on.

How can Middle Managers build trust with senior leaders?

Trust grows when they share clear facts, explain risks early, and follow through. Leaders value steady, honest input more than perfect answers.

Why do Middle Managers feel stuck between team needs and leadership plans?

They hear pressure from both sides. They support people while advancing plans. That tension sits at the heart of the role.

How can Middle Managers protect their energy during constant change?

Small habits help, like short resets, clear priorities, and honest boundaries. These simple steps keep stress from taking over the week.